Spotted AI text?Why detectorsoften get it wrong
Anyone who checks texts wants to know whether a person or a machine wrote them. What the research says, where AI detectors fail and what matters for your own content.
Get in touch- Can AI-written text be detected at all?
- How to tell if text is AI the way trained readers do
- What does ChatGPT text detection actually measure?
- Can AI detectors be wrong, and how often?
- What a count of German texts shows about humanizing AI text
- Does AI-written content hurt your Google ranking?
- Must AI-written text be labelled and detectable in the EU?
- How do you humanize AI text so it sounds like you?
- Frequently asked questions
- How to handle AI-written text and AI detectors in your company
- Where the information on this page comes from

Let's talk about your project.
First we check whether the project fits your business model. Then you get a proposal with phases and effort.
Discuss text review or call: +49 151 1576 5566Can you detect AI-written text just by reading it? Usually not. In a large study, readers without practice did no better than chance. People who write a lot with ChatGPT themselves, on the other hand, get it right almost every time, because they know where to look. AI detectors rely on similar signals (word choice, sentence structure), but all they return is a probability, and they keep flagging plain, clear human writing as machine-made.
- Untrained readers spot AI text about as well as a coin toss; frequent ChatGPT users are almost always right.
- A detector measures how a text is built. It cannot prove who wrote it.
- Google asks whether content helps, not how it was produced.
On this page
- Can AI-written text be detected at all?
- How to tell if text is AI the way trained readers do
- What does ChatGPT text detection actually measure?
- Can AI detectors be wrong, and how often?
- What a count of German texts shows about humanizing AI text
- Does AI-written content hurt your Google ranking?
- Must AI-written text be labelled and detectable in the EU?
- How do you humanize AI text so it sounds like you?
- Frequently asked questions
- How to handle AI-written text and AI detectors in your company
- Where the information on this page comes from
Can AI-written text be detected at all?
Yes, AI-written text can be detected, just not the way most people think. In a 2023 study published in PNAS, researchers showed around 4,600 participants short self-descriptions of the kind you find in professional profiles, holiday rental listings or dating profiles, and asked: human or machine? Participants were right 50 to 52 percent of the time. A coin would have done just as well.
What we find more interesting than the rate is what people relied on. A spelling mistake, a sentence starting with “I”, a mention of family, and a text was judged human, even though these features say almost nothing about where a text came from.
The picture changes completely when the judges write with ChatGPT a lot themselves. In a University of Maryland study, five such heavy users assessed 300 non-fiction articles, and their majority vote classified 299 of them correctly, including texts that had been paraphrased afterwards (presented in 2025 at ACL, the leading computational linguistics conference). Practice beats gut feeling, and anyone who reviews texts for a living can learn it.
How to tell if text is AI the way trained readers do
In ChatGPT text, detection most often starts with word choice. Language models have favourite words; in English the classic is “delve”, which turned up so often in scientific abstracts after 2023 that researchers used it to estimate how much of an entire year's output was written with AI help: at least 13.5 percent of the 2024 abstracts, with “delves” appearing 28 times more often than expected.
The second clue is sentence structure, and in AI text it is remarkably well-behaved. Sentences run to roughly the same length, there are lots of nouns, and nothing snags. A 2025 analysis in PNAS counted this across thousands of texts and found chat models using far more nominalisations than people. Oddly enough, the raw base versions of the same models, before they were trained to give friendly chat answers, wrote more like humans.
What we notice most when reading, though, is the missing stance. People write “I think” or “probably” when they are not sure, and in a comparison of argumentative essays they did so more often than ChatGPT, which prefers smooth statements.
| Signal | Typical of AI text | Typical of human text |
|---|---|---|
| Word choice | Recurring pet words, polished filler | Plain, sometimes unusual, very specific words |
| Sentence length | Even, mostly medium | Varies a lot, the occasional very long sentence |
| Structure | Lists of three, “not only … but also” | Irregular, with asides and brackets |
| Stance | Smooth statements | Hedges such as “probably” or “I think” |
| Repetition | Swaps synonyms but repeats ideas | Repeats simple words, rarely whole ideas |
What does ChatGPT text detection actually measure?
Every AI detector, whatever its accuracy, rests on a surprisingly simple idea. A language model picks words that another language model can predict well, whereas people reach for a word nobody saw coming more often. How surprising a text is to a model is called perplexity. And for how much that varies from sentence to sentence, the detector company GPTZero popularised the term burstiness.
Newer tools compare two models with each other, or learn from large collections of known human and machine texts how the two differ. In the end there is always a number, usually shown as a percentage. That number describes the statistics of the text, not who wrote it, and the difference is easy to overlook.
Can AI detectors be wrong, and how often?
Yes, AI detectors can be wrong, and more often than the percentage suggests. Even OpenAI, the company behind ChatGPT, took its own detector offline again in July 2023 because it was not accurate enough. By OpenAI's own published figures, it correctly flagged only 26 percent of AI texts and wrongly labelled 9 percent of human texts as AI-written.
It gets really uncomfortable for people who write plainly and clearly. In 2023 a research team ran English essays through seven common detectors: essays written for a language test by non-native speakers were classified as AI 61 percent of the time on average, while essays by American eighth graders were sorted almost perfectly. Why? A simple vocabulary is predictable, and predictability is exactly what detectors react to.
So a single detector score is a hint, nothing more. Anyone who uses it to judge a job application, a term paper or a supplier they want to accuse may be treating unfairly someone who simply writes cleanly.
What a count of German texts shows about humanizing AI text
Almost all studies on detecting AI-written text work with English, so we counted for German ourselves. On one side were 155 newspaper and trade articles written by people, on the other 65 texts from a current language model (Claude) on similar topics.
We did not expect the clearest result, because it contradicts a popular writing rule. Short sentences are not a sign of a human; long ones are. In the human texts, 15.6 percent of sentences had 25 words or more, in the model's texts only 2.8 percent, and the model wrote twice as many very short sentences. Brackets like these (for a thought that occurs to you along the way) appeared regularly in human writing and not once in the typical model text, and words like “probably” behaved the same way.
Of course 220 texts are not a large study, and a count like this says nothing about which text is better. It does show one thing you will not find in most style guides: if you build every paragraph from short, punchy sentences, you now sound more like a machine than a person.
Does AI-written content hurt your Google ranking?
No, AI content does not hurt your Google ranking, at least not because an AI wrote it. Back in February 2023, Google stated that its search rewards helpful, reliable content however it is produced. What Google does not like are pages produced in bulk mainly to show up in search results while offering readers little; since March 2024 that counts as spam, whether a person or a machine wrote it.
So the old questions still decide. Is what it says true? Does someone arriving with a specific question find the answer here, or just sentences they have read many times before? And can you tell that someone who knows the subject stands behind it? How Google assesses this is covered in our article on E-E-A-T.
Must AI-written text be labelled and detectable in the EU?
Whether AI-written text has to be labelled and made detectable depends on who you are and what it is for. Article 50 of the EU AI Act first obliges the providers of AI systems to mark their output in a machine-readable way, for new systems since 2 August 2026, and for systems already on the market before that from 2 December 2026. Anyone who publishes texts informing the public on matters of public interest must disclose that they were generated by AI, unless a person has reviewed them editorially and takes responsibility for them.
For typical business content, product pages or a newsletter that someone in your company reads and approves anyway, this is unlikely to trigger a labelling duty. Chatbots that talk directly to your customers are a different matter; what applies there is explained in our article on AI disclosure for chatbots, and how providers mark their texts technically is covered in the article on watermarks in AI text.
How do you humanize AI text so it sounds like you?
Not with tricks meant to fool AI detectors, which can be wrong in both directions anyway. They change nothing about whether a text is any good, and anyone who suddenly finds slang in a product description senses the intent. What helps is old-fashioned craft: follow a thought through even if the sentence gets longer, say where you are not sure, and prefer the precise word over the general one (instead of “an important feature”, say what the feature saves your customer).
At our company every text goes through two checks before it is published: one on facts, with two independent sources for each claim, and one on style. We use the detector only as a warning light, and when it goes off, it is usually because of paragraphs that neatly summarise what was already said. We cut those, and the text gets shorter and better.
Frequently asked questions
Can you prove a text was written by ChatGPT?
No, not with a detector. It calculates a probability and can be wrong in both directions. Invisible watermarks that some providers build into their output come closer to proof, but they also disappear once someone rewrites the text thoroughly.
Are free AI detectors accurate?
Nobody knows exactly, because hardly any provider discloses how its tool works. What is known is the weak spot: with plainly written texts and with people writing in a language that is not their first, detectors raise false alarms remarkably often.
Does Google know if content was written by AI?
For rankings, Google says it does not matter. In 2023 the company stated that it rewards good content however it is produced. Trouble comes to pages mass-produced to occupy search results, whether a person or a machine wrote them.
How can I make AI-written text sound more human?
Treat it like a draft from a new colleague. Check the claims, cut the filler, add your own experience, and let a long sentence stand now and then. Deliberate typos do not help; they measurably cost readers' trust.
Can I use AI-written text on my website?
Yes. But you are responsible for what it says, just as with anything you wrote yourself. If the topic is of public interest, it is worth checking Article 50 of the EU AI Act.
Can teachers and reviewers spot AI text?
That depends on how much they write with AI themselves. The heavy users in the 2025 study were almost always right; readers without that experience were barely better than a coin toss in other research.
How to handle AI-written text and AI detectors in your company
- 01
Set up sign-off
Decide who reads AI drafts and who is accountable for them being correct.
- 02
Check facts twice
Every figure and every name needs a source that someone on your team has actually read.
- 03
Use detectors as a warning light
If a detector flags a text, take a second look at the sentences. Do not use it to judge people.
- 04
Clarify labelling
For chatbots and texts on public-interest topics, check whether Article 50 of the EU AI Act applies.
A detector tells you how a text is built. Whether it is true and sounds like you, you still have to read for yourself.
AI agentsAgentic AI Explained: What It Means for Your Business
Google spam update recoveryGoogle Spam Update Recovery: Find the Cause Before You Fix
AI agent vs chatbotAI Agent vs Chatbot: The Difference and When Each One Fits
SEO vs GEOSEO vs GEO: What Stays the Same and What Changes
Zero-click searchZero-Click Search: What the Studies Show and What to Do
Google indexingRequest Indexing on Google: What the Button Really Does
AI Act loggingAI Act Logging Requirements: What Applies and When
SEO visibility indexSEO Visibility Index: What It Measures and What It Misses
RAGWhat Is RAG in AI? Retrieval Augmented Generation Explained
Gemini 4 ArgonGemini 4 Argon: What the Model Is Actually Built For
Computer useComputer Use Agent: What It Operates and What It May Do
AI voice agentAI Voice Agent Pricing: Cost per Call and Disclosure
Google spam updateGoogle Spam Update: What Can Your Numbers Really Tell You?
LLM costsLLM Cost Optimization: When a Model Switch Pays Off
Google AI ModeGoogle AI Mode: What It Means for Your Website
AI agentsWhat Is an AI Agent, and How Is It Different From a Chatbot?
Structured DataStructured Data: What It Really Does for AI Search
AI AssistantAI Assistant for Business: Types, Uses and Data Protection
GEOE-E-A-T: Trust Signals for Google and AI Search
Local AILocal AI for Business: What “Local” Really Means
GEOAI Crawlers in robots.txt: Managing GPTBot and Co.
AI for SMEsAI for SMEs: How to Introduce AI Step by Step
Perplexity SEOPerplexity SEO: How to Get Your Site Cited as a Source
ChatGPT SEOChatGPT SEO: How to Get Your Business Found in ChatGPT
llms.txtllms.txt: What the File Does and When It Pays Off
AI SEOAI SEO: What Changes Compared to Traditional SEO
AI OverviewsGoogle AI Overviews: How Google Picks Its Sources
GEO vs AEO vs LLMOGEO vs AEO vs LLMO: The AI Search Terms Explained
Measure AI VisibilityMeasure AI Visibility: Method, Metrics and Limits
ChatGPT AdsChatGPT Ads: How to Advertise on ChatGPT in Germany
AI Literacy ObligationAI Literacy Obligation: What Article 4 Requires Since 2026
AI DisclosureAI Chatbot Disclosure: Article 50 in Practice
AI Text WatermarkAI Text Watermark: What Claude Marks and What It Doesn't
Where the information on this page comes from
- Jakesch, Hancock, Naaman (2023): Human heuristics for AI-generated language are flawed, PNASaccessed 26 Sep 2026
- Russell, Karpinska, Iyyer (2025): People who frequently use ChatGPT for writing tasks are accurate and robust detectors of AI-generated text, ACLaccessed 26 Sep 2026
- Reinhart u. a. (2025): Do LLMs write like humans?, PNASaccessed 26 Sep 2026
- Herbold u. a. (2023): A large-scale comparison of human-written versus ChatGPT-generated essays, Scientific Reportsaccessed 26 Sep 2026
- Kobak u. a. (2025): Delving into LLM-assisted writing in biomedical publications, Science Advancesaccessed 26 Sep 2026
- Liang u. a. (2023): GPT detectors are biased against non-native English writers, Patternsaccessed 26 Sep 2026
- Google Search Central: Google Search's guidance about AI-generated contentaccessed 26 Sep 2026
- Verordnung (EU) 2024/1689 (KI-Verordnung), Artikel 50accessed 26 Sep 2026
- The Register: OpenAI quietly shuts down its AI detection tool (26.07.2023)accessed 26 Sep 2026
- Google Search Central: What web creators should know about our March 2024 core update and new spam policiesaccessed 26 Sep 2026
- Muñoz-Ortiz, Gómez-Rodríguez, Vilares (2024): Contrasting linguistic patterns in human and LLM-generated news text, Artificial Intelligence Reviewaccessed 26 Sep 2026


